![]() |
Words and photo by F LoBuono |
Like most
Americans, I support a reasonable, sustainable, effective, compassionate
immigration policy, one that we have been lacking for far too long. However,
like many other Americans but unfortunately not most, I am shocked and
appalled at how the use of mass deportations qualifies as ANY sort of immigration
policy. And I’m not even talking just about those sent to the hellish,
draconian prisons that are more like death camps. I’m writing of the
thousands of families, the great majority of them hardworking people who
provide essential services to our Country. They want nothing more than to live
in peace but have been sent cruelly packing. Even sick children under treatment
have been given the boot. It’s unconscionable.
It seems
that salacious and false accusations about these communities have been allowed
to flourish under the current Trump Administration creating an atmosphere of fear
and loathing for these people, thereby justifying their cruel actions.
Here’s is just one example: Kristi Noem, Secretary of Homeland
Securities, appears in several commercials, properly attired in combat gear,
hair beautiful quaffed, bright blue eyes shining, praising the leadership of
her boss, President Trump, adding how many violent criminals were
rounded up and deported under his watch, making us all that much safer. Sounds impressive, right? We all want that,
right? Here are some facts that show that to be nothing more than fear-mongering
hyperbole:
When looking specifically
at the relationship between undocumented immigrants and crime, researchers come
to similar conclusions. Numerous studies show that undocumented
immigration does
not increase violent crime; research
examining crime rates in so-called sanctuary cities also found no
discernable difference when compared to similarly situated cities without
sanctuary policies. One study that focused on drug crimes and driving under the
influence found that
unauthorized immigration status was associated with reductions in arrests for
those offenses.*
Those are the REAL numbers but let me contribute further
with some personal anecdotes to add even more context. My partner Amanda and I
live in a very modest house at the corners of Jackson Avenue and North Mill
Street in Nyack, NY. I call it the Crossroads of The World. Well, at
least it is to me, both literally and figuratively. Jackson Avenue had once
been the center of a thriving Black neighborhood filled with other modest homes
and successful businesses. But in the 1960’s, in response to the creation of
nearby Nanuet Mall, the downtown businesses felt they needed a large
parking lot to be able to compete with the new mall. So, here comes Urban
Renewal and the village council decided to create the lot by bulldozing the
most vulnerable neighborhood – the black one, of course. Well, they may have
gotten most of it, but not all. What’s left is still a vibrant, active, tight
block where WE are now in the minority. And love it. The whole neighborhood is
filled with the sound of (mostly brown) children and the smell of delicious
ethnic food in the air. The music is mostly Tejano and so much fun to
listen to. There is a large family behind us who regularly put up a big, blue
tarp, cook, sing, and laugh well into the evening. But, by 10-1030pm the tarp
is down, and the place is quiet. It’s very respectful. Just the other day, one
of the families across the street had a Quinceanera celebration. I
stopped and watched with total enjoyment as they turned their backyard parking
lot into a dance floor! All the young men were wearing black suits topped by
black Stetsons. All the girls were dressed in colorful, frilly dresses. I broke
into the biggest smile as they preceded to execute their perfect dance moves.
It was wonderful!
Then, the other day, I watched a smallish, Latina woman push
a shopping cart FULL of I assume the week’s laundry up the steep hill that is
Jackson Ave. I offered to help. She smiled and said, “no, gracias.” It was her
regular routine. We’ve never had an issue with stolen items, violence, noise or
any other crime or nuisance so often blamed on immigrant communities.
And THESE are the people we are supposed to fear and loath? I’ll
never get it because I see people who are clean, family oriented, hardworking,
and have a lust for life! These are ALL the things I WANT in my life – I need
in my life. They don’t detract from our lives – they ADD to them. It’s as
simple as treating ALL human beings with the respect they deserve. Who gives a
crap where they come from? I am not afraid! Let them be who they are and give
some of it back to us. If we do, the world is a much better place. And it
shouldn’t be that hard. It ain’t – to me.
*https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/debunking-myth-migrant-crime-wave